Showing posts with label Barbara Hammers. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Barbara Hammers. Show all posts

Wednesday, September 28, 2011

What is this case about?

In re: Marriage Of Fong is an instructional case for civil litigation, and therefore is famous among family attorneys.  But what does this mean for the lay person going through a divorce, and why is it important to know about?

Here's my two cents:  watch what your attorney is doing.  So many parties going through litigation blindly trust their attorneys, without trying to verify their work.  The internet is a great place to search for any topic regarding your case.  And if you search for "discovery" rules in divorce cases, chances are you'll wind up with a search result of "In re: Marriage Of Fong".

What happened to Marci is huge.  I can't say whether she was watching over what her attorney was doing, but had her attorney been working for me, I would've caught the simple error that made the case so famous.  Her attorney neglected to file mandatory disclosure forms (typically just a few pages) and this wound up costing Marci $200,000.

A San Jose law firm (almadenvalleylawyers.com) posted the following for couples on their law blog:

Selecting an attorney is a very important decision, and in my experience - I've found it quite common that attorneys tend to overpromise and do more talking and bluffing than prudently and carefully practicing good law.  My attorney, Casey Olsen, is very fastidious, and with nearly 30 years of practice as a trial lawyer, he did a great job and deserves his prestigious reputation.

But it doesn't take an exceptional lawyer to fill out the simple disclosure courts that are required by the courts.  This is a basic requirement that any practicing attorney should know.  And just because an attorney has passed the bar or talks up a good storm doesn't mean you shouldn't watch what he/she is doing.  In this case, it cost the client $200,000.

Wednesday, March 23, 2011

Correction On Facts

*** UPDATE *** COURT OF APPEALS REPUBLISHED THE DECISION TO CORRECT OUR FACTUAL CORRECTIONS BELOW!  click here for link

After reading the Appeals decision, while we are thrilled that we beat all odds and got the decision overturned, one thing that really stood out to myself and Casey was where the court wrote that I never responded to any settlement offers, and that my conduct in the trial rose to the level of a $100,000 fee award.  Here's some reasons why:
  1. Judge Juhas made a determination that our settlement offer was reasonable, whereas Marci's was "totally unreasonable".  That is not conducive to settlement when your settlement offer is 5x over what the court found. 
  2. Marci filed a divorce suit in Canada, seeking property division and support, and soon after being turned away for support in Los Angeles, she went to Canada.  This is commonly known as "forum shopping", and the Canadian court sanctioned her for this action.
  3. Barbara Hammers, according to sworn testimony, told a witness that her settlement strategy was to "ask for the moon".  This pressures the other party into an unfair settlement, and is confrontational.  Hammers then told the witness if "Gary wanted to do that, the cost would be prohibitive, because 'the person with the most money pays all the fees in a divorce."
  4. Marci claimed an ownership interest in my invention, "The Lightsphere" because years before the Lightsphere was invented, I fashioned tissues into the shape of a Coleman Lantern, and that was the basis for a multimillion-dollar settlement.
  5. Marci sought "permanent spousal support" of $10,000 a month, after we were divorced, and despite the fact that she left a well-paying ($60,000 a year) job to move to Seattle to live with a man she had met on the internet.
  6. Marci Kington's expert witness Donald J. Miod testified in court that his analysis for the domain name garyfong.com was $1.8 million dollars, because we were one of the pioneers of website traffic. (The judge ruled Miod's opinion was "flawed in many respects" and ruled that the website was worth less than $5,000)
  7. I believe the testimony from Pictage's counsel Josh Baker, of O'Melveny & Myers, speaks for itself regarding the conduct of Marci (who was represented at the time by Barbara K. Hammers) in a motion to compel a witness.
  8. Attorney Barbara K. Hammers and Armine Baltazar filed and argued in court that I should be thrown in jail in contempt for an order that I had paid in full for attorney's fees.  That hearing was thrown out in minutes.
  9. Attorney Barbara K. Hammers contacted one of my deposition witnesses to "warn" him that he was being subpoena'd for a deposition should he "plan to try to avoid it".
Those eight instances are expanded to further detail below.


Deposition of Barbara Hammers, Attorney

One of the most unusual things I've seen is my attorney deposing the opposing counsel.  Barbara Hammers insisted that she be deposed to "set the record straight" that she never made representations to me that she would assist in mediating a settlement for both of us, even though I paid her retainer fee and even though she told me she would take care of both of us (she's a friend of my friend).  Then she asked to be "deposed" to set the record straight.

Here is an excerpt from her deposition.  (To see the whole deposition, click here).  Two things I find noteworthy about her deposition is 1) she's testifying here about the legal advice she's giving me and 2) she denies that she ever offered to assist in mediating a settlement between us and 3) she knows that disclosures are required by law:



For a case that has become a famous landmark decision for the fact that Barbara Hammers did not file the final declaration of disclosure as required by law (and lost her client $200,000 on appeal after her client was billed nearly a million dollars in fees in this matter), she certainly appears to know that it's important.  I have no idea why she didn't file it - I've been asked this many times by attorneys, and all I can say is - I wasn't surprised.  

We were ordered by the judge to file our F.D.D.'s by a certain date.  There's an excuse floating around in the internet world that this might not have been required by the rules or a controversy over the dates, but on the record the judge ordered us to both produce the FDD's in a status discussion.  That wasn't clearly published in the appeals declaration, but the order is on the record.

*** UPDATE ***
to read the NEW republished decision (after their failed motion for rehearing): click here

Not allowing the accountants to meet

One of the more frustrating aspects of this case was trying to get our forensic accountants to meet so they could compare numbers and agree on what the property division would be.  Normally, forensic accountants (in the course of settlement discussions) get together and compare their figures and how they come up with their numbers.

There should be no "bullying" or pressure tactics.  There should be an earnest effort by both sides to come to an agreement.

This is especially difficult when the attorney of the opposing counsel refuses to let the accountants meet.  Here is a copy of the letter from lawyer Barbara Hammers describing why she and her client to do not wish for the attorneys to meet:


This obviously was a huge roadblock to settling the case.  In fact, settling became impossible when the forensics weren't allowed to meet!

On August 5, 2009, here's what the Judge, Mark A. Juhas said regarding the accountants not meeting: (to see the trial transcript - click here)


In the end, we got sanctioned for not being cooperative in discovery?  The court system is hugely clogged right now, and I just honestly think sometimes the judges are so buried that its' hard for them to remember the details of cases by the time they issue their rulings.

Tuesday, March 22, 2011

►BARBARA HAMMERS' CRIMINAL CONTEMPT HEARING



This is the official trial transcript of the criminal contempt trial hearing of Marci Kington vs. Gary Fong. Attorneys Barbara K. Hammers and Armine Baltazar of Hammers & Baltazar, LLC.

In this motion, for lawyer Barbara Hammers is arguing to press criminal charges here (with a possible jail sentence) in a contempt order, even though she admitted knowing that the order had been paid in full, 2) she never served the order and 3) there is no debtor's prison in California.

Once attorney Casey Olsen demonstrated that service had not been done, attorney Barbara Hammers then argues that service isn't necessary -

Lawyer Casey Olsen states again for the record that the underlying order had been paid in full, and Lawyer Barbara Hammers agrees:


Debtor's Prison: You cannot be thrown in jail for owing money.  This is in the California State Constitution.  However, Attorney Barbara Hammers still attempts to argue that the court can order a prison sentence (even though the entire amount had been paid!)

She goes on to argue that you do not need to serve a party for the fees order...


Then she represents to the court that, even though service wasn't required, that she did serve me anyway...



The judge wasn't convinced - and ruled that I had not been served by Barbara Hammers, even though she just testified above that she had.


I believe that this case is famous for an attorney losing the appeal for basically failing to file basic forms that are required by the rules of the court.  

In this instance, not only did Barbara Hammers not serve the notice, she got paid in full and then continued to push for a criminal hearing, even though you cannot be incarcerated for attorney or accounting fees!  The court agreed:

It was nice not being put in jail, despite Barbara Hammer's extreme efforts.  I would have been more upset if my life wasn't otherwise so happy.

Thursday, March 17, 2011

Not My First Rodeo

I find it very disconcerting that attorneys and other legal professionals can be tempted to wield  powers of intimidation to threaten people or make their lives more uncomfortable by the deterrent of expensive legal fees.

Typically, this type of behavior does not go with impunity. Years ago, I was plaintiff in a federal lawsuit (full jury trial) where the behavior of the opposing counsel was so bold that he got sanctioned by federal judge and ordered to pay personally over $15,000 for his behavior.


The attorney, David E. Newhouse,  sent me a personal check as he was ordered to by Judge Audrey B. Collins. Having been through that situation, I pretty much believed that there was some semblance of control over attorney behavior.

But this isn't really the case in family law.  It is quite different in family law. While there are intelligent and talented judicial officers at every level, in federal courts, the judges are appointed by the President of the United States, whereas in family courts, you may get a Commissioner who is a attorney and not elected judicial official.

Still, I feel that overall (even though it may take years and years) the reputation of legal professionals eventually gets out into the open. Here is the order from the judge sanctioning David E. Newhouse. Now that I reflect on how Barbara Hammers tried to have me thrown in jail for paying a $90,000 attorney fee award in payments (even though she never served on me), I'm pretty sure that the oversight on the attorney behavior is not the same in family courts as it is at the federal level.